Again Sutton and Epsom Find a Way Away

image_pdfimage_print

Old Elthamians 17 – Sutton & Epsom 20 14th November.

Regional 2 South East returned to action after a Saturday of recuperation, international rugby and the usual plethora of social activities. This was the first time Old Elthamians had hosted Sutton & Epsom since November 2011 when they triumphed 27-6. The men from Rugby Lane will always have a place in OE history as the Old Boys’ first fixture on 27th January 1912 was against the Sutton & Epsom ‘A’ XV.

Fortunes have fluctuated since that historic day and this was only the third league meeting of the clubs. S&E arrived trailing the leaders Beckenham by a solitary point with only a singular loss to Medway. In contrast, the hosts, following a meteoric recent rise, had just a singular win over Hammersmith & Fulham on their early season record. If the casual observer of the league table thought that this was going to be one-way traffic, they were in for a shock as the Black & Whites scraped home 20-17.

Sutton & Epsom had three enforced changes, with Messrs Jones, O’Brien and Scott replaced by the triumvirate of Duey, McCormack and debutant Davies on the bench. The sides kicked off the second six-match block of the campaign that will take the league up to the festive break.

It was a dry and sunny afternoon as a sizeable crowd viewed the spectacle either from the well-appointed stand or enjoyed the ambience of the touchline. The opening minute was a microcosm of the first-quarter exchanges. Sutton & Epsom advanced through several phases with excellent continuity only to be terminated by the shrill blast of Mr Oliver Tyson’s whistle for an infringement on the deck.

This scenario was repeated several times and without discrimination to whomsoever was attacking. Kudos to the defences and the spoiling back rows, but it was ultimately frustrating for coaches and crowd alike.

In the third minute, from one of these penalties, the hosts failed to find touch in the corner but picked off an interception as S&E attempted to run it from the 22. Sutton & Epsom were saved by excellent defence.

Sutton & Epsom opened the scoring in the eighth minute. Momentum from the catch and drive at the lineout put them on the front foot. Adam Bibby made the critical break and passed the ball to the inside, and Angus Findlay headed straight for the corner, outpacing the cover from 40 metres. Freddy Bunting added the extras with an excellent touchline conversion for a 7-0 lead.

Five minutes later the Sutton & Epsom pack excelled at the lineout. Taking the ball 20 metres out, they trundled remorselessly to what appeared to be an inevitable try for hooker Sam Lennie. However, they were denied at the key moment by staunch defence. From the OE scrum, number eight Reis Norman made one of his many impressive carries and the hosts cleared their lines.

At the end of the first quarter the game altered in complexion as Sutton & Epsom received the first of two yellow cards. Prop Tom Boaden departed after head contact at a ruck. S&E absorbed the initial numerical punishment and added to their account via a penalty from 40 metres from the Bunting boot.

Straight after going 10-0 up, Josh Glanville went down injured and, heaping Pelion onto Ossa, he was also issued a yellow card. For the Rugby Lane travelling cohort it was Medway revisited as their XV was now a XIII. Unsurprisingly Old Elthamians, greatly encouraged by Sutton & Epsom’s indiscipline, began to dominate possession and territory. Impressively the Surrey men lasted until Boaden’s return.

In the final minute of normal time in the first half, OEs were finally rewarded. Controlling several phases in the 22, they moved towards the uprights and the ball was passed to Reis Norman, who scored. It was a deserved reward for his excellent contribution in the first half. The conversion failed as OEs trailed 5-10.

Though Sutton & Epsom were now restored to their full complement, Old Elthamians monopolised the seven minutes of time added on. The Queen Mary’s crowd were rewarded with the equalising score in the dying embers of the half. Matt Chick put the finishing touches on a wonderful passage of play for the hosts’ second try.

The conversion was missed but the rampant Kent side went into the break level at 10-10. The Black & Whites had much to mull over during the interval. The momentum was definitely with the 11th-placed side in the table as the team one off the top were threatened with the prospect of the shock result of Round 7.

Second-half battle

Old Elthamians started the second period buoyed by their two tries at the end of the first half and looked odds-on to take the lead in the opening moments. The ball was hacked forward and two Old Boys led the chase, but a cruel bounce deceived the first, who knocked it on, thus nullifying the effort of the second.

The hosts held the upper hand in the third quarter but the stalemate continued despite the bulldozing efforts of Reis Norman. Once more penalties hindered the progress of both sides as they slugged it out in the middle third of the paddock.

The game exploded into life in the final quarter. Sutton & Epsom debutant Alex Davies carried the ball into OE territory. Jack Howes burst forward from the breakdown and found the open spaces only to be felled by a tap tackle, but after a theatrical forward roll he continued his run.

The cover defence finally halted him in the 22 but the Sutton & Epsom support brought the ball under the posts. It was shipped wide and Josh Rea timed his arrival to perfection to crash over the whitewash for the try. Freddy Bunting added the conversion for 17-10.

If the Rugby Lane followers thought that this was the moment that turned the tide, they were proved premature a minute later. Replacement Sam Tilley, in the centres, hit the line with power and pace near halfway with devastating effect to run in under the posts untouched. Joe Leigh added the simplest of conversions and it was level, once more, at 17-17.

After two tries in as many minutes the game reverted to the industrious arm wrestle of before as both teams looked for that decisive moment of inspiration.

With five minutes left on the clock, with Sutton & Epsom on the attack, the Kent men conceded a penalty through a deliberate knock-on. It was within the scope of Freddy Bunting and adjacent to the posts. The kick for goal was chosen and no one watching was surprised when he bisected the uprights for 20-17.

The sands of time were running out for Old Elthamians as the match entered time added on. However, experienced watchers of the Black & Whites knew that there would inevitably be one moment of high anxiety.

The referee awarded a penalty but, in contrast to S&E, OEs opted for the kick to the corner as they sought victory from the final play of the game. The ball was arrowed into the corner. However, to the dismay of the home crowd, a scrappy lineout followed. As the ball hit the deck, desperate forwards foraged for possession. Referee Tyson spotted an infringement and ended the contest.

Another narrow victory

The volume of the Sutton & Epsom jubilation was a fair indication of the relief they felt in their narrow 20-17 win.

After the final whistle those with a Sutton & Epsom connection could reflect on Isaiah Berlin’s theory of ‘hedgehogs and foxes’, inspired by the writing of Grecian satirist Archilochos. The Black & Whites had found another different route to victory, indicating membership of the vulpine category rather than a one-dimensional prickly clan.

The fact that they had not reached the dizzying heights of the Horsham win was credit to Old Elthamians, who belied their lowly status in the table.

Reis Norman excelled in a fine performance from their back row alongside Hans Laud-Anderson and Matt Chick. The front row trio of Widdowson, Noah and Trew provided the platform for Messrs Leigh and Robertson to excel in the backs.

For S&E it was a truly collective effort led by skipper Hegarty, with a timely reminder of the value of the Bunting boot.

League leaders next at Rugby Lane

S&E return to Rugby Lane next Saturday for the Clash of the Titans as the visitors are league leaders Beckenham.

Since Sutton & Epsom’s arrival in 2024-25 in Regional 2 South East, this fixture has had the most dramatic of conclusions, with all three meetings culminating in the last kick of the game.

First there was a minuscule miss from a touchline penalty from halfway, that was followed by a charged-down drop goal, and last season Tom Lennard’s penalty gave Sutton & Epsom a 20-17 win.

One would hope that current form and recent history translate into a bumper crowd at Rugby Lane.

John Croysdill

Team line-ups

Sutton & Epsom: Lennard, McCormack, Bibby, Maxwell, Findlay A, Bunting, Findlay E, Johnson, Lennie, Boaden, Duey, Glanville, Tame, Rea and Hegarty (captain).

Replacements: Howes, Davies A and Munford.

Old Elthamians: Leigh, Neicho, Coppard, Robertson (captain), Beadle, Day, Davies, Widdowson, Noah, Trew, Ryan, Ranson, Chick, Laud-Anderson and Norman.

Replacements: Sanger, Reed and Tilley.

© 2021-2026. No content may be copied without the permission of Epsom and Ewell Times Ltd.